In the case of Coscarella Dentistry Professional Corporation v. Harvey, 2025 ONCA 118, two dentists entered into an oral agreement where one served as an independent contractor at the other’s dental practice located in Windsor, Ontario. In 2018, the plaintiff/appellant’s son took over the clinic. Concurrently, the defendant/respondent opted to relocate his practice to a nearby site. Prior to his departure, he accessed patient records of those he had treated and sent out letters informing them of his new office location. The appellants contended that this constituted improper solicitation, conversion, and a breach of confidentiality. The trial judge decided in favor of the defendant/respondent, rejecting the claims made against him. During the appeal, the appellants contended that the trial judge misinterpreted the case by emphasizing patient autonomy over contractual responsibilities. They further argued that the trial judge incorrectly determined that the accessed information was not confidential and did not adequately … Read More